The efficiency of macrocyclization reactions relies on the appropriate conformational preorganization of a linear precursor, ensuring that reactive ends are in spatial proximity prior to ring closure. Traditional peptide cyclization approaches that reduce the extent of terminal ion pairing often disfavor cyclization-conducive conformations and can lead to undesired cyclodimerization or oligomerization side reactions, particularly when they are performed without high dilution. To address this challenge, synthetic strategies that leverage attractive noncovalent interactions, such as zwitterionic attraction between chain termini during macrocyclization, offer a potential solution by reducing the entropic penalty associated with linear peptides adopting precyclization conformations. In this study, we investigate the role of (N-isocyanoimino)triphenylphosphorane (Pinc) in facilitating the cyclization of linear peptides into conformationally rigid macrocycles. The observed moderate diastereoselectivity is consistent with the preferential Si-facial addition of Pinc, where the isocyanide adds to the E-iminium ion on the same face as the l-proline amide group. The resulting peptide chain reveals that the activated phosphonium ylide of Pinc brings the reactive ends close together, promoting cyclization by enclosing the carboxylate within the interior of the pentapeptide and preventing the formation of byproducts. For shorter peptides with modified peptide backbones, the cyclization mechanism and outcome are redirected, as nucleophilic motifs such as thiazole and imidazole can covalently trap nitrilium intermediates. The isolation of the intermediate in the unproductive macrocyclization pathway, along with nuclear magnetic resonance and density functional theory studies, provides insights into heterocycle-dependent selectivity. The Pinc-driven macrocyclization process has generated diverse collections of cyclic molecules, and our models offer a comprehensive understanding of observed trends, facilitating the development of other heterocycle-forming macrocyclization reactions.