To attain posterior medialization by thyroplasty type I, we simulated the surgery using 3 cadaveric larynges. Two approaches were applied to adduct the arytenoid cartilage: one involved compression of the vocal process, and the other, compression of the muscular process inward. The inner perichondrium was incised to reach the arytenoid cartilage from the framework. To compress the vocal process, a large silicone plug was required. In this method, there was some difficulty in compressing the vocal process precisely, and there was the risk of postoperative extrusion of the large plug. In contrast, the muscular process was more superficial relative to the framework, and it could be precisely compressed, resulting in sufficient posterior glottal closure. The silicone plug required for this procedure has a shallow depth that may provide the advantage of preventing postoperative extrusion. In conclusion, the compression of the muscular process is preferable for safely achieving posterior glottal closure.