Callaghan has suggested that the most important factor in obtaining optimal results after total hip arthroplasty may be the ability to determine when to use cemented or cementless fixation. This article has presented the indications and relative contraindications for use of proximally porous-coated prostheses. Midterm results suggest that with appropriate patient selection, excellent clinical results can be achieved with currently available proximally porous-coated prostheses. Use of proximally coated prostheses is indicated for primary total hip arthroplasty in patients aged >70 years with good bone stock. Relative contraindications are based on interference with bone ingrowth or with the ability to achieve a congruent fit, both of which preclude establishment of rigid initial stability. These conditions include metabolic bone disease such as osteoporosis, osteomalacia, Gaucher's disease, sickle cell disorders, and Paget's disease; significant anatomical distortion, as seen in developmental dysplasia of the hip with anteversion, prior osteotomy, or intertrochanteric fracture; Dorr type C bone; and current treatment with radiation, chemotherapy, indomethacin, or diphosphonates. The same relative contraindications to use are applicable in revision situations. Further, proximally porous-coated prostheses should not be used for revision arthroplasty in the setting of massive bone loss, limited life expectancy, or inability to participate in protected weight bearing. These devices may be used successfully in revision arthroplasty when the hip has minimal or moderate bone loss, and occasionally in the setting of severe bone loss. As further information is revealed through the long-term (10-20 years) results of proximally coated prostheses, further refinements and knowledge of the indications and contraindications for the use of these prostheses will be revealed.