Class I cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterases (PDEs) share a catalytic domain containing 18 invariant residues. In cGMP-binding cGMP-specific PDE (PDE5), we showed previously that point mutation of nine of these profoundly decreases k(cat) when the assay is conducted in the presence of Mg(2+); seven of these are in the prototypical metal-binding motifs A and B (HX(3)HX(n)()E) that we identified earlier. Tandem arrangement of two of these metal-binding motifs in PDEs is novel, and whether residues within these motifs are involved in metal support of catalytic activity is a fundamental question in this field. This report shows that mutation of either His-607 (A motif) or His-643 (B motif) to alanine profoundly diminishes support of PDE catalysis by Mn(2+) or Mg(2+), but mutation of His-647 in B motif or of Glu in either motif does not. H607A and H643A mutants have much greater maximum catalytic rates supported by Mn(2+) than that by Mg(2+); catalytic activity of H603A mutant is supported weakly by either. In H607A and H643A, K(a)s for Mn(2+) and Mg(2+) are increased, but the effect of Mn(2+) is 2-fold greater than that of Mg(2+) in each. Mutation of any of the other conserved residues (Asn-604, Asp-644, His-675, Asp-714, and Asp-754) causes unremarkable changes in Mn(2+) or Mg(2+) support of catalysis. This study identifies specific residues in PDE5 that contribute to interactions with catalytically relevant metals. The combined data suggest that despite a high degree of sequence similarity between each HX(3)HX(n)()E motif in PDEs and certain metallo-endopeptidases, PDEs employ a distinct complement of residues for interacting with metals involved in catalysis.