It is proposed that damage to the masticatory system from intense parafunction can be assessed more accurately by the Weak Link Theory. The theory predicts that the more intense and the more prolonged the forces, the more the tendency of damage to either. 1. the periodontal tissue; 2. the teeth; or 3. the orofacial structures. To test the theory, 22 subjects were selected based on reports of nocturnal bruxism. Each was assessed for masticatory system breakdown on the Russell Periodontal Index, the Helkimo Dysfunction Index, and a Tooth Wear Index. A Bruxcore (Forgione, A. 1974 J Dent Res 53:127) was used to obtain an objective score of bruxism. Five of eleven subjects with mild bruxism scored high on only one index. Significantly more subjects (ten of eleven) with moderate to severe bruxism scored high on one index only.