Behavioral choice can be mediated either by a small number of sharply tuned neurons or by large populations of broadly tuned neurons. This issue can be conveniently examined in the turtle spinal cord, which generates each of three forms of scratching-rostral, pocket, and caudal-in response to mechanical stimulation in each of three adjacent regions of the body surface. Previous research showed that many propriospinal neurons are broadly tuned to either the rostral scratch region or the pocket scratch region, but responses to caudal scratch stimulation could not be examined in that reduced preparation. In the current study, individual spinal neurons were recorded extracellularly from the gray matter of the turtle spinal cord hindlimb enlargement, while sites in the rostral, pocket, and caudal scratch regions were mechanically stimulated. Many neurons were broadly tuned to the caudal scratch region; other neurons were broadly tuned to either the pocket scratch or rostral scratch region. All three types were typically found within a single animal. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that the turtle spinal cord relies on large populations of broadly tuned neurons to select each of the three forms of scratching. In addition, neurons that were broadly tuned to each of the scratch regions were typically found in each spinal cord segment and within the same range of mediolateral and dorsoventral locations. Providing that these neurons are related to the selection and generation of the three forms of scratching, this would indicate that cells of this type are not segregated into distinct regions of the spinal cord gray matter.