Potential donor nerves for autografting are finite and usually limited to cutaneous nerves of the extremities. The superficial peroneal nerve is the major lateral branch of the common peroneal nerve that innervates the peroneus longus and brevis muscles and provides sensation to the lateral aspect of the lower leg and the dorsal foot. It has generally been overlooked as a potential donor of nerve autografts. Cadaver dissections were performed on 10 fresh lower extremity specimens to investigate the anatomic characteristics of the superficial peroneal nerve and to refine a harvesting technique for the nerve. Thirty-one patients underwent nerve grafting of 39 upper and lower extremity nerves using the superficial peroneal donor. There were nine median nerves, four ulnar nerves, two radial nerves, two brachial plexus lesions, 16 digital nerves, and six lower extremity nerves grafted. The superficial peroneal nerve provided a consistently long donor, comparable in length to the sural nerve. The anatomic pattern is consistent, the patient positioning is simple, the surgical harvesting technique is straightforward, and the donor defect is acceptable. The superficial peroneal nerve provides a safe and valuable donor nerve, particularly in cases where multiple or very long nerve grafts are required.