Laboratory- and pilot-scale racemic polylactides (PLA50) were synthesized in the presence of stannous octoate (SnOct2) or zinc-metal as initiators in the absence of alcohol. The resulting polymers were processed by compression molding or injection molding depending on the batch scale. The hydrolytic degradation of compression-molded samples selected to be comparable was investigated first in order to show the influence of the initiator system. Differences in water uptake were found between PLA50-Zn (zinc-metal initiation) and PLA50-Sn (SnOct2 initiation). PLA50-Zn being much more hydrophilic. PLA50-Sn exhibited a slower molecular weight decrease and delayed onsets of weight loss, release of acidity and stereocomplex formation, with respect to PLA-Zn. The concentration in residual tin in PLA50-Sn increased from 306 to 795 ppm during aging. In the case of PLA50-Zn the residual metal remains constant at ca. 40 ppm. In a second series of experiments, high molecular weight PLA50 different in characteristics and in initiator, synthesized under pilot-scale, were compared. The effects of the initiator on the degradation of the polymers well agreed with laboratory-scale findings, differences in hydrophobicity being enlarged by the up scaling. PLA50-Sn polymers appeared much more degradation resistant than PLA50-Zn ones. Contributions of the other characteristics (e.g. molecular weight, purity, stereoregularity, processing) were shown to be important as well.