A concise, highly efficient formal total synthesis of dl-physostigmine is described, using a relatively simple method that should be adaptable to the synthesis of homologous members of this type of alkaloid. The key step in the synthesis is a new vicarious nucleophilic substitution reaction between p-nitroanisole and a C-silylated derivative of N-methylpyrrolidinone. Subsequent conversion of the initial adduct to the tricyclic framework of physostigmine follows a well-established protocol and provides the key intermediate 8 in high yield. The vicarious nucleophilic substitution reaction has also been extended to six-membered lactams, with encouraging results.