Intermediates formed during reduction of Fe(2)(mu-PPh(2))(2)(CO)(6) (1) in the presence of protons have been identified by spectroelectrochemical, continuous-flow, and interrupted-flow techniques. The mechanism for electrocatalytic proton reduction suggested by these observations yields digital simulation of the voltammetry in close agreement with measurements conducted in THF over a range of acid concentrations. The mechanism for electrocatalytic proton reduction involves initial formation of the dianion, 1(2-), which is doubly protonated prior to further reduction and dihydrogen elimination. The IR spectra of the singly and doubly protonated forms of 1(2-) indicate structures corresponding to [FeH(CO)(3)(mu-PPh(2))(2)Fe(CO)(3)](-) (1H-) and FeH(CO)(3)(mu-PPh(2))(2)FeH(CO)(3) (1H(2)). The thiolato and dithiolato analogues of 1 exhibit electrocatalytic proton reduction associated with the two-electron reduction step, and this implies that the corresponding two-electron reduced doubly protonated species is unstable with respect to dihydrogen elimination. The stability of 1H(2) is most likely to be due to the weak interactions between the iron centers of the flattened [2Fe2P] core. Whereas 1H(2) is stable in the absence of a reducing potential, 1H- rearranges rapidly to a product previously described as [Fe(2)(mu-PPh(2))(mu-CO)(PHPh(2))(CO)(5)](-) (1H-(W)). Another protonation product of 1(2-), previously formulated as [Fe(2)(mu-PPh(2))(2)(mu-CO)H(CO)(5)](-), has been reformulated as [Fe(2)(mu-PPh(2))(mu-CO)(CO)(6)](-) (2) on the basis of a range of spectroscopic measurements. Solution EXAFS measurements of 1, 1(2-), 1H-(W), and 2 are reported, and these yield model-independent Fe-Fe distances of 2.61 (1), 3.58 (1(2-)), 2.58 (1H-(W)), and 2.59 A (2). The presence of an Fe-Fe bond for both 1H-(W) and 2 is a key aspect of the proposed structures, and this strongly supports the deductions based on spectroscopic evidence. The fits of the solution EXAFS to different structural models give statistics in agreement with the proposed structures.