Objectives: One of the early hypotheses relating sleep disturbances in depression to a model of sleep regulation is the S-deficiency hypothesis. It is postulated that, in depressed patients, sleep propensity during wakefulness does not rise to the level attained by nondepressed subjects, resulting in altered sleep structure or changes in the electroencephalogram during sleep. We aimed to test this hypothesis by assessing topographic changes in the sleep electroencephalogram associated with depression.
Design: Cross-sectional clinical study.
Setting: Mental Health Clinical Research Center.
Participants: Sixteen unmedicated depressed outpatients (mean age: 41.2 years) and 16 pair-matched healthy controls (mean age: 41.1 years).
Interventions: None.
Measurements: Baseline sleep electroencephalogram recordings were obtained from a central referential electrode and from 3 bipolar derivations (frontocentral, centroparietal, parietooccipital) along the anteroposterior axis.
Results: Symptoms of depression at the time of sleep recordings were moderate (24-item Hamilton Rating Scale of Depression range: 16-31). No differences between patients and controls were found in sleep variables and all-night electroencephalogram spectra in non-rapid-eye-movement and rapid-eye-movement sleep. The ultradian modulation of slow-wave activity (power within 0.75-4.5 Hz), as well as the exponential decline of slow-wave activity, during sleep did not differ between the groups. The statistical analyses of electroencephalogram power gradients between adjacent derivations revealed no Group x Derivation interactions. An anterior dominance in non-rapid-eye-movement sleep power was present in the 0.75- to 2-Hz range, which diminished throughout the night.
Conclusions: These findings in moderately depressed patients do not support the existence of an S-deficiency during sleep. Because the build up of sleep propensity during waking can be dissociated from its decline, future studies need to investigate the waking electroencephalogram spectra in depression.