Our increasing appreciation of the high prevalence of mixed-species Plasmodium infection in malaria-endemic regions has resulted in controversy regarding the likely mechanism(s) of regulation for mixed parasite burden within an individual human host. In the present study, we examined dynamic models of Plasmodium spp. regulation by fever and by non-specific (NS) and species-specific (SS) immunity (including the influence of their variable time-delays, duration, and efficacy) in order to assess the likely role of these factors in regulating detectable parasitemia and clinical disease. Our models suggest that in order to observe the irregular waves of fever and parasitemia that are often found in multiply infected subjects, there must be a differential SS immune effect (beyond the regulatory effects of the species-transcendent density-dependent factors previously posited to control mixed-species parasitemia), and time-dependent variation in immunity to the dominant species. By implementation of individual SS immune controls of non-permanent duration, the resulting multi-dimensional model can be viewed as multiple single-species oscillators coupled via a NS species-transcendent controller. This extended model exhibits the essential patterns of long-term mixed infections. Although this 'circuit-immunity' model gives only a qualitative estimate of the complex web of participating agents and reaction pathways, it provides a starting point for future studies of the specific and NS within-host mechanisms that regulate mixed-species malaria infection.