A previous structure-activity investigation of acetylcholine (ACh) revealed a positive correlation between additional hydrophobic bulk and increased potency for inhibition of active transport of [3H]ACh by synaptic vesicles isolated from the electric organ of Torpedo. In the current study, several ACh analogues that are significantly larger than previously studied "false transmitters" were synthesized in the tritiated form by chemical means and tested for active transport. These are analogue 14 [(+/-)-(cis,trans)-1-benzyl-1-methyl-3-acetoxypyrrolidinium iodide], analogue 15 [(+/-)-1,1-dimethyl-3-benzoyloxypyrrolidinium iodide], and analogue 16/17 [(+/-)-(cis,trans)-1-benzyl-1-methyl-3-benzoyloxypyrrolidinium iodide]. These analogues place significant additional hydrophobic bulk on one or the other (analogues 14 and 15) or both (analogue 16/17) of the two pharmacophores of a small, conformationally constrained analogue of ACh. [3H]Analogue 14 and [3H]analogue 15 are actively transported, with Vmax values the same as or less than that of ACh, depending on the vesicle preparation. The observation that Vmax is the same for an analogue and ACh in some vesicle preparations suggests that the rate-limiting step does not involve ACh bound to the transporter. [3H]Analogue 16/17 is actively transported very poorly. Km values for ACh and for transported ACh analogues vary by up to two- to threefold in different vesicle preparations. The ACh transporter is much less selective for transported substrates than anticipated.