Substrate channeling in the tryptophan synthase bienzyme complex is regulated by allosteric signals between the alpha- and beta-active sites acting over a distance of 25 A. At the alpha-site, indole is cleaved from 3-indole-D-glycerol 3'-phosphate (IGP) and is channeled to the beta-site via a tunnel. Harris and Dunn [Harris, R. M., and Dunn, M. F. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 9982-9990] showed that when the novel amino acid, dihydroiso-L-tryptophan (DIT), reacts with the beta-site, the alpha-aminoacrylate Schiff base, E(A-A), is formed and the enzyme releases indoline. The indoline produced exits the enzyme via the tunnel out the open alpha-site. When the alpha-site ligand (ASL) alpha-D,L-glycerol 3-phosphate (GP) binds and closes the alpha-site, indoline generated in the DIT reaction is trapped for a short period of time as the quinonoid intermediate in rapid equilibrium with bound indoline and the E(A-A) intermediate before leaking out of the closed enzyme. In this work, we use the DIT reaction and a new, high-affinity, ASL, N-(4-trifluoromethoxybenzenesulfonyl)-2-amino-1-ethyl phosphate (F9), to explore the mechanism of ligand leakage from the closed enzyme. It was found that F9 binding to the alpha-site is significantly more effective than GP in trapping indoline in the DIT reaction; however, leakage of indoline from the enzyme into solution still occurs. It was also found that a combination of benzimidazole (BZI) and GP provided even more effective trapping than F9. The new experiments with F9 and the combination of BZI and GP provide evidence that the coincident binding of GP and BZI at the alpha-site exhibits a strong synergistic effect that greatly slows the leakage of indoline in the DIT reaction and enhances the trapping effect. This synergism functions to tightly close the alpha-site and sends an allosteric signal that stabilizes the closed structure of the beta-site. These studies also support a mechanism for the escape of indoline through the alpha-site that is limited by ASL dissociation.