Further Analysis of Contraceptive Failure of the Ovulation Method

Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1991 Dec;165(6 Pt 2):2054-9. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9378(11)90581-x.

Abstract

Reanalysis of data on the ovulation method of natural family planning collected by the World Health Organization yields the following conclusions. The method is effective during perfect (correct and consistent) use, with a first-year probability of failure of 3.4%. However, it is extremely unforgiving of imperfect use, with a first-year probability of failure of 84.2% if the method is not used correctly. During the initial year, 87% of the cycles were characterized by perfect use. Nevertheless, the 13% of cycles characterized by imperfect use had a tremendous impact on the overall failure rate. During the first year of typical use 22.5% of the women in the clinical trial became accidentally pregnant.

PIP: Re-analysis of data collected from clinical trials of the ovulation method (OM) of natural family planning (NFP) delineated failure rates for both perfect and imperfect use during the teaching phase, the effectiveness phase, and the actual 1st year of use, and offered computed failure rates for various types of use errors. The data, originally published in 1981, covered 765 women in the teaching phase (2701 cycles), and 725 in the effectiveness phase (7514 cycles), from New Zealand, India, Ireland, Philippines and El Salvador. In this study rules for the teaching phase differed significantly from the effectiveness phase, with total abstinence required for the 1st cycle, and more restrictions in the teaching phase generally. The data suggested that errors were underreported, and that failure rates were higher than those typically reported in other studies. Except for the 1st cycle, cycles with no intercourse were eliminated from analysis. 2.0% conceived in the 1st cycle, as 46% had coitus. Life table probabilities of pregnancy were 22.0% in the 1st year, 3.2% in perfect use and 84.1% in imperfect use. Failure rates per cycle in the teaching phase (cycles 2-6), 0.22% failure with perfect use, and 9.9% with imperfect use, were similar to those in the effectiveness phase, 0.24% for perfect use and 14.4% with imperfect use. The most risky behaviors were having intercourse on wet/mucus days, within 3 days after the peak, during stress, on the peak day or around a 2nd peak (90% failure rate). Moderately risky behaviors were intercourse during mischarted cycles, spotting/bleeding days, having genital contact on wet days (50%). Intercourse on consecutive early days was least risky (16.6%). By plotting the percent failing in the 1st year as a function of per cycle failure rates for perfect and imperfect use, it was concluded that the OM is fairly effective if used perfectly, extremely unforgiving of imperfect use, and moderately difficult to use perfectly. If underreporting is taken into account, the conclusion would be that OM is moderately effective if used perfectly, and very difficult to use perfectly.

Publication types

  • Research Support, U.S. Gov't, Non-P.H.S.

MeSH terms

  • Adult
  • Contraception*
  • Evaluation Studies as Topic
  • Family Planning Services
  • Female
  • Humans
  • Life Tables
  • Ovulation / physiology*
  • Probability
  • World Health Organization