Skip to main page content
Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
, 76 (3), 535-60

Asymmetry in Judgments of Personality: Others Are Less Differentiated Than the Self


Asymmetry in Judgments of Personality: Others Are Less Differentiated Than the Self

Andrew Beer et al. J Pers.


Previous evidence suggests that judges rely more heavily on implicit personality theories when they rate relatively unfamiliar others. One further implication of this evidence is that correlations among traits should be stronger in other ratings than in self-ratings, particularly when (a) judges lack trait relevant information and/or (b) motivational accuracy is low. We tested these predictions by comparing self- versus other ratings on the Big Five in two studies. Study 1 used previously published data to demonstrate clear self/peer differences in the average relations between Big Five dimensions (excluding Extraversion). Study 2 was based on self- versus other ratings in 12 samples. Overall, the intercorrelations among Big Five traits (excluding Extraversion) tended to be significantly stronger in peer ratings than in self-ratings. The most consistent effect involved the relation between Neuroticism and Agreeableness (overall r=-.43 and -.29 in the peer ratings and self-ratings, respectively). In addition, as expected, the degree of relation among traits varied depending upon the type of target being rated (i.e., spouse vs. dating partner vs. friend vs. stranger). Implications of these findings are discussed.

Similar articles

See all similar articles

Cited by 2 PubMed Central articles

  • Comparability of Self- And Other-Rated Personality Structure
    H Nuzum et al. Psychol Assess 31 (6), 741-750. PMID 30730190.
    It is commonly accepted that gathering information via multiple assessment methods (e.g., interview and questionnaire, self- and informant report) is important for establ …
  • Personality Judgments From Everyday Images of Faces
    CA Sutherland et al. Front Psychol 6, 1616. PMID 26579008.
    People readily make personality attributions to images of strangers' faces. Here we investigated the basis of these personality attributions as made to everyday, naturali …

Publication types

LinkOut - more resources