OPTN policy regarding prioritization of patients with hepatopulmonary syndrome: does it provide equitable organ allocation?

Am J Transplant. 2008 May;8(5):954-64. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-6143.2007.02124.x.


United Network for Organ Transplantation (UNOS) policy provides exception points to patients diagnosed with hepatopulmonary syndrome (HPS) to compensate for their reported increased mortality risk. We compared pre- and posttransplant and overall outcomes in 255 patients receiving exception points under this policy (HPS policy patients) with 32 358 nonexception control patients listed in the model for end-stage liver disease (MELD) era to determine whether the intent of the policy is being met. Overall, 92.5% of HPS policy patients versus 45.5% of controls had been transplanted, 5.1% versus 31.2% remained on waiting list and 1.5% versus 14.1% had died while awaiting transplant (p < 0.0001 for each comparison). Relative risk (RR) of death for HPS policy patients compared to controls was 0.158 (confidence interval [CI]: 0.059-0.420, p = 0.0002) pretransplant, and 0.827 (CI: 0.587-1.170, p = 0.28) posttransplant. Overall (combined waitlist and posttransplant) RR of death was 0.514 (CI: 0.374-0.707, p = 0.00004) compared with controls. After adjustment for laboratory MELD, overall RR was 0.807 (CI: 0.587-1.110, p = 0.19), indicating that HPS policy patients' mortality risk would be similar to that of controls had they been listed with their laboratory MELD score. HPS policy patients have a significant pretransplant survival advantage over standard liver transplant candidates because of the exception points awarded, and have similar posttransplant survival. Better criteria for diagnosing and grading of HPS are required.

MeSH terms

  • Health Care Rationing / standards*
  • Health Policy*
  • Hepatopulmonary Syndrome / surgery*
  • Humans
  • Liver Transplantation / statistics & numerical data*
  • Patient Selection
  • Resource Allocation / methods*
  • Resource Allocation / statistics & numerical data
  • Tissue and Organ Procurement / methods*
  • Tissue and Organ Procurement / standards*
  • Tissue and Organ Procurement / statistics & numerical data
  • United States
  • Waiting Lists