The aim of the study was to test whether the source of intracellular calcium (Ca2+) is a determinant of beta cell function. We hypothesized that elevations in cytosolic Ca2+ caused by the release of Ca2+ from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) have little physiologic impact on oxygen consumption and insulin secretion. Ca2+ release from the ER was induced in isolated rat islets by acetylcholine and response of oxygen consumption rate (OCR), NAD(P)H, cytosolic Ca2+, and insulin secretory rate (ISR) were measured. Glucose increased all four parameters, and thereafter acetylcholine further increased cytosolic Ca2+, OCR, and ISR. To assess the contribution of Ca2+ release from the ER in mediating the effects of acetylcholine, ER Ca2+ stores were first emptied by inhibiting the sarcoendoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase, which subsequently reduced the effect of acetylcholine on cytosolic Ca2+ but not its effects on OCR or ISR. As predicted, OCR and ISR were acutely sensitive to changes in L-type Ca2+ channel activity; nimodipine completely inhibited glucose-stimulated ISR and suppressed OCR by 36%, despite only inhibiting cytosolic Ca2+ by 46%. Moreover, in the presence of nimodipine and high glucose, acetylcholine still elevated cytosolic Ca2+ levels above those observed in the presence of high glucose alone but did not significantly stimulate ISR. In conclusion, Ca2+ flux through L-type Ca2+ channels was tightly coupled to changes in OCR and ISR. In contrast, the results obtained support the notion that Ca2+ release from the ER has little or no access to the intracellular machinery that regulates OCR and ISR.