The Notch pathway is a short-range signaling mechanism between neighboring cells that results in changes in gene expression. Extracellular interactions between Notch receptors and ligands trigger proteolytic cleavage of the receptor Notch. Following cleavage, the freed intracellular domain of Notch (NotchIC) moves from the cytoplasm to the nucleus, engaging the DNA-binding transcription factor CBF-1, Su(H), Lag-1 (CSL)--the nuclear effector of the pathway. NotchIC, together with the transcriptional coactivator Mastermind, form a ternary complex with CSL that activates transcription from genes that are responsive to Notch signaling. Illuminating the molecular details that underlie formation of the transcriptionally active CSL-NotchIC-Mastermind ternary complex is key for understanding how genes are turned on in response to a Notch signal. Recently, several studies using biophysical and computational methods have scrutinized how the CSL-NotchIC-Mastermind ternary complex forms and the role individual domains play in this process. These detailed analyses have provided a wealth of molecular insights into the assembly of a Notch pathway active transcription complex but have also raised several intriguing, yet confounding questions. This review will focus on the findings of these recent biophysical studies and provide speculative models that address these unanswered questions.