Autoimmune pancreatitis is highly responsive to steroid therapy, but because it mimics pancreatic cancer, it often precipitates unnecessary surgery. Adequate diagnostic tests are needed to permit appropriate medical therapy. Lymphocytic and obliterative phlebitis are reported in the majority of cases, as are elevated IgG4-positive plasma cells, indicating their high sensitivity. Their specificities, especially when used in conjunction, however, remain largely unknown. Movat pentachrome vascular and IgG4 immunohistochemical stains were performed on a total of 15 autoimmune pancreatitis cases (11 pancreatic resections and 4 biopsies), 39 usual-type alcoholic or idiopathic chronic pancreatitis cases, 35 pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma-associated chronic pancreatitis cases, and 29 normal pancreata. Marked and diffuse lymphocytic and obliterative venulitis were detected in all 15 cases of autoimmune pancreatitis on Movat staining (100% sensitivity). Only a single carcinoma-associated chronic pancreatitis case among all of the controls showed diffuse benign venulitis that was nonobliterative (99% specificity). Nine of 13, 9 autoimmune pancreatitis cases showed marked IgG4 immunopositivity at >or=10 positive plasma cells per x 400 field (69% sensitivity). No increased IgG4 plasma cells were found in any of 103 controls (100% specificity). In combination, all of the autoimmune pancreatitis cases had at least one (13/13) and most had both markers (9/13), whereas none of the controls had both markers. Overall, these combined stains show very promising diagnostic utility and should be considered in combination with clinical and serologic analyses in the evaluation of chronic pancreatitis suspicious for malignancy. Future validating studies on preoperative biopsies with outcome data following steroid therapy will be essential.