Skip to main page content
Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
, 12 (3), 333-43

Causal Criteria and the Problem of Complex Causation


Causal Criteria and the Problem of Complex Causation

Andrew Ward. Med Health Care Philos.


Nancy Cartwright begins her recent book, Hunting Causes and Using Them, by noting that while a few years ago real causal claims were in dispute, nowadays "causality is back, and with a vengeance." In the case of the social sciences, Keith Morrison writes that "Social science asks 'why?'. Detecting causality or its corollary-prediction-is the jewel in the crown of social science research." With respect to the health sciences, Judea Pearl writes that the "research questions that motivate most studies in the health sciences are causal in nature." However, not all data used by people interested in making causal claims come from experiments that use random assignment to control and treatment groups. Indeed, much research in the social and health science depends on non-experimental, observational data. Thus, one of the most important problems in the social and health sciences concerns making warranted causal claims using non-experimental, observational data; viz., "Can observational data be used to make etiological inferences leading to warranted causal claims?" This paper examines one method of warranting causal claims that is especially widespread in epidemiology and the health sciences generally-the use of causal criteria. It is argued that cases of complex causation generally, and redundant causation-both causal overdetermination and causal preemption-specifically, undermine the use of such criteria to warrant causal claims.

Similar articles

  • The Role of Causal Criteria in Causal Inferences: Bradford Hill's "Aspects of Association"
    AC Ward. Epidemiol Perspect Innov 6, 2. PMID 19534788.
    As noted by Wesley Salmon and many others, causal concepts are ubiquitous in every branch of theoretical science, in the practical disciplines and in everyday life. In th …
  • From Correlation to Causation: What Do We Need in the Historical Sciences?
    MC Ebach et al. Acta Biotheor 64 (3), 241-62. PMID 27364751.
    Changes in the methodology of the historical sciences make them more vulnerable to unjustifiable speculations being passed off as scientific results. The integrity of his …
  • Causation in the Sciences: An Inferentialist Account
    J Reiss. Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci 43 (4), 769-77. PMID 22883394.
    I present an alternative account of causation in the biomedical and social sciences according to which the meaning of causal claims is given by their inferential relation …
  • An Introduction to Causal Inference
    J Pearl. Int J Biostat 6 (2), Article 7. PMID 20305706. - Review
    This paper summarizes recent advances in causal inference and underscores the paradigmatic shifts that must be undertaken in moving from traditional statistical analysis …
  • On the Use of Causal Criteria
    DL Weed. Int J Epidemiol 26 (6), 1137-41. PMID 9447391. - Review
    Research on causal inference methodology should be encouraged, including research on underlying theory, methodology, and additional systematic descriptions of how causal …
See all similar articles

Cited by 2 PubMed Central articles


    1. Epidemiol Perspect Innov. 2004 Oct 04;1(1):3 - PubMed
    1. Kidney Int. 2007 Sep;72(6):671-5 - PubMed
    1. Drug Saf. 2007;30(4):333-46 - PubMed
    1. Med Health Care Philos. 2009 Mar;12(1):77-90 - PubMed
    1. Am J Public Health. 2005;95 Suppl 1:S144-50 - PubMed

LinkOut - more resources