Varicoceles are a treatable cause of male infertility, but very clinically diverse. Both histologic and molecular changes occur in the testes of men with varicocele. Physical measurements (scrotal temperature, testicular volume, pressure within the pampiniform plexus, basal lamina thickness) correlate with prognosis, but these correlations have not been accepted as predictors of successful repair because of variation within patient populations. Conventional semen parameters similarly correlate, but these correlations apply only to men with >5 x106 sperm/ejaculate. Levels of toxicants (e.g. norepinephrine, cadmium), reactive oxygen species byproducts, and hormones, their receptors and modulators have been evaluated as predictors in small-scale studies. Medical therapies (antoxidants, anti-inflammatories and hormones) have been applied empirically to small groups of patients with positive results that have not been verified in large-scale trials. Thus, urologists still face a challenge to determine which patients will benefit from varicocelectomies and/or medical interventions. In this review we summarize our current understanding of the pathophysiology of varicoceles, and discuss some of the new findings that may be applicable to specific clinical situations.