Perturbation analysis was used to determine the relative contribution of target enhancement and noise cancellation in the identification of rudimentary sound source in noise. In a two-interval, forced-choice procedure, listeners identified the impact sound produced by the larger of two stretched membranes as target. The noise on each presentation was the impact sound of a variable-sized plate. For four of five listeners, the relative weights on the noise were positive indicating enhancement, and for the remaining listeners, they were negative indicating cancellation. The results underscore the difficulty with evaluating models of masking solely in terms of measures of performance accuracy.