Bacterial cytochrome c peroxidase (CcP) enzymes are diheme redox proteins that reduce hydrogen peroxide to water. They are canonically characterized by a peroxidatic (called L, for "low reduction potential") active site heme and a secondary heme (H, for "high reduction potential") associated with electron transfer, and an enzymatic activity that exists only when the H-heme is prereduced to the Fe(II) oxidation state. The prereduction step results in a conformational change at the active site itself, where a histidine-bearing loop will adopt an "open" conformation allowing hydrogen peroxide to bind to the Fe(III) of the L-heme. Notably, the enzyme from Nitrosomonas europaea does not require prereduction. Previously, we have shown that protein film voltammetry (PFV) is a highly useful tool for distinguishing the electrocatalytic mechanisms of the Nitromonas type of enzyme from other CcPs. Here, we apply PFV to the recently described enzyme from Geobacter sulfurreducens and the Geobacter S134P/V135K double mutant, which have been shown to be similar to members of the canonical subclass of peroxidases and the Nitrosomonas subclass of enzymes, respectively. Here we find that the wild-type Geobacter CcP is indeed similar electrochemically to the bacterial CcPs that require reductive activation, yet the S134P/V135K mutant shows two phases of electrocatalysis: one that is low in potential, like that of the wild-type enzyme, and a second, higher-potential phase that has a potential dependent upon substrate binding and pH yet is at a potential that is very similar to that of the H-heme. These findings are interpreted in terms of a model in which rate-limiting intraprotein electron transfer governs the catalytic performance of the S134P/V135K enzyme.