Skip to main page content
Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
Review
, 366 (1574), 2076-85

The Levels of Analysis Revisited

Affiliations
Review

The Levels of Analysis Revisited

Scott A MacDougall-Shackleton. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci.

Abstract

The term levels of analysis has been used in several ways: to distinguish between ultimate and proximate levels, to categorize different kinds of research questions and to differentiate levels of reductionism. Because questions regarding ultimate function and proximate mechanisms are logically distinct, I suggest that distinguishing between these two levels is the best use of the term. Integrating across levels in research has potential risks, but many benefits. Consideration at one level can help generate novel hypotheses at the other, define categories of behaviour and set criteria that must be addressed. Taking an adaptationist stance thus strengthens research on proximate mechanisms. Similarly, it is critical for researchers studying adaptation and function to have detailed knowledge of proximate mechanisms that may constrain or modulate evolutionary processes. Despite the benefits of integrating across ultimate and proximate levels, failure to clearly identify levels of analysis, and whether or not hypotheses are exclusive alternatives, can create false debates. Such non-alternative hypotheses may occur between or within levels, and are not limited to integrative approaches. In this review, I survey different uses of the term levels of analysis and the benefits of integration, and highlight examples of false debate within and between levels. The best integrative biology reciprocally uses ultimate and proximate hypotheses to generate a more complete understanding of behaviour.

Similar articles

  • Social Plasticity in Fish: Integrating Mechanisms and Function
    RF Oliveira. J Fish Biol 81 (7), 2127-50. PMID 23252731. - Review
    Social plasticity is a ubiquitous feature of animal behaviour. Animals must adjust the expression of their social behaviour to the nuances of daily social life and to the …
  • Morphology and Behaviour: Functional Links in Development and Evolution
    RC Bertossa. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 366 (1574), 2056-68. PMID 21690124.
    Development and evolution of animal behaviour and morphology are frequently addressed independently, as reflected in the dichotomy of disciplines dedicated to their study …
  • [Schizophrenia in the Light of the Evolutionary Theories]
    D Wiener et al. Psychiatr Pol 37 (4), 601-13. PMID 14560490. - Review
    The aim of the article was to review the hypotheses of schizophrenia in the light of the evolutionary theory. The authors distinguished adaptationist and non-adaptationis …
  • Experimental Evolution and Proximate Mechanisms in Biology
    X Yi. Synth Syst Biotechnol 2 (4), 253-258. PMID 29552649. - Review
    Biological functions - studied by molecular, systems and behavioral biology - are referred to as proximate mechanisms. Why and how they have emerged from the course of ev …
  • An Evolutionary Framework for Studying Mechanisms of Social Behavior
    NESCent Working Group on Integrative Models of Vertebrate Sociality: Evolution, Mechanisms, and Emergent Properties et al. Trends Ecol Evol 29 (10), 581-9. PMID 25154769. - Review
    Social interactions are central to most animals and have a fundamental impact upon the phenotype of an individual. Social behavior (social interactions among conspecifics …
See all similar articles

Cited by 7 PubMed Central articles

See all "Cited by" articles

Publication types

LinkOut - more resources

Feedback