Sepsis is a major health problem in the United States with high incidence and elevated patient care cost. Using an animal model of sepsis, cecum ligation, and puncture, we observed that mice became rapidly hypothermic reaching a threshold temperature of 28 °C within 5-10 h after initiation of the insult, resulting in a reliable predictor of mortality, which occurred within 30-72 h of the initial procedure. We also observed that the inflammatory gene expression in lung and liver developed early within 1-2 h of the insult, reaching maximum levels at 6 h, followed by a decline, approaching basal conditions within 20 h. This decrease in inflammatory gene expression at 20 h after cecal ligation and puncture was not due to resolution of the insult but rather was an immune dysfunction stage that was demonstrated by the inability of the animal to respond to a secondary external inflammatory stimulus. Removal of the injury source, ligated cecum, within 6 h of the initial insult resulted in increased survival, but not after 20 h of cecal ligation and puncture. We concluded that the therapeutic window for resolving sepsis is early after the initial insult and coincides with a stage of hyperinflammation that is followed by a condition of innate immune dysfunction in which reversion of the outcome is no longer possible.