Effect of size and site on the outcome of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy of proximal urinary stones in children

Abstract

Objective: To determine the effect of location and size of stones on the outcome of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL) in children.

Patients and methods: In 2008-2010, 150 children (median age 6.6 years) with radio-opaque ureteric and renal stones measuring ≤4 cm were treated. Exclusion criteria were coagulation disorders, pyelonephritis, distal obstruction, non-functioning kidney and hypertension. ESWL was performed under general anesthesia. Follow up period was 5-22 months.

Results: 186 stones were treated: 76 calyceal, 92 pelvic and 18 proximal ureteral. Mean stone size was 1.3 cm. A total of 312 sessions were performed (mean per stone = 1.67 sessions). The mean number of shock waves per session was 2423.68. Overall stone-free rate was 89.24%. Having a calyceal location did not significantly affect the stone-free rate (p = 0.133). The failure rate was significantly higher (66.7%) in stones >3 cm in size (p < 0.001). Complications were encountered in 18 patients; 2 underwent auxillary ureteroscopy and 4 uretrolithotomy for treatment of steinstrasse.

Conclusion: ESWL is a safe and effective method for treatment of stones up to 2 cm in children. Rate of auxillary procedures increases in stones >2 cm in size. About 80% of failures were associated with stone size >1.35 cm while 52.3% of completely cleared stones were associated with size <1.35 cm.