The boutonniere deformity is the most common rheumatoid thumb deformity. It can be classified into early, moderate, and advanced types, depending on whether the deformity is passively correctable. Fifty-three patients with 74 procedures form the basis of these recommendations. The early type treated with metacarpophalangeal joint synovectomy and extensor pollicis longus rerouting have a high recurrence rate of 64%. Metacarpophalangeal joint fusion is the procedure of choice for the moderate type with isolated metacarpophalangeal joint involvement. Metacarpophalangeal joint arthroplasty is best suited for the low-demand, older patients with borderline proximal and distal joints. Interphalangeal joint releases done with metacarpophalangeal joint fusions have a high recurrence rate and are not recommended. In advanced cases metacarpophalangeal joint arthroplasty and interphalangeal joint fusion is our procedure of choice.