This study derived an embedded performance validity indicator for the Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test (AVLT) using an archival dataset. Participants aged 20 to 65 (N = 167) who reported traumatic brain injury and completed at least two performance validity tests were included. The group who passed all performance validity measures (n = 68) demonstrated higher scores on all AVLT trials than the group who failed two or more validity indicators (n = 62). Bayesian model averaging was used to identify the optimal combination of AVLT variables for group discrimination; Total Learning and Recognition raw scores were selected. Logistic regression using these variables showed excellent discrimination with an area under the curve of. 85. The resulting AVLT performance validity index demonstrated sensitivity of. 55 with specificity of. 91. Further study of this index is warranted and cross-validation is recommended prior to clinical use.