Injuries to the subtalar joint are often associated with fractures of the talus or calcaneum. These injuries often lead to degenerative changes resulting in pain, restriction of movement and difficulty in weight bearing. This can cause significant deformity and disability for the patient. Occult injury of the subtalar joint has been described as an isolated event or in association with a subluxation/dislocation of this joint. They are difficult to assess with plain radiography therefore, they are generally diagnosed with advanced imaging like CT scan or MRI scan. We present a case of a 66-year-old man who presented with destructive chondrolysis of the subtalar joint 2 years following conservative treatment of a minimally displaced distal fibular fracture. It was treated by subtalar and talonavicular arthrodesis. Overall, the patient made an excellent recovery and was satisfied with the outcome.