Youden index and Associated Cut-points for Three Ordinal Diagnostic Groups

Commun Stat Simul Comput. 2013 Jan;42(6):1213-1234. doi: 10.1080/03610918.2012.661906.

Abstract

Directly relating to sensitivity and specificity and providing an optimal cut-point which maximizes overall classification effectiveness for diagnosis purpose, the Youden index has been frequently utilized in biomedical diagnosis practice. Current application of the Youden index is limited to two diagnostic groups. However, there usually exists a transitional intermediate stage in many disease processes. Early recognition of this intermediate stage is vital to open an optimal window for therapeutic intervention. In this paper, we extend the Youden index to assess diagnostic accuracy when there are three ordinal diagnostic groups. Parametric and nonparametric methods are presented to estimate the optimal Youden index, the underlying optimal cut-points and the associated confidence intervals. Extensive simulation studies covering representative distributional assumptions are reported to compare performance of the proposed methods. A real example illustrates the usefulness of the Youden index in evaluating discriminating ability of diagnostic tests.

Keywords: Youden index; bandwidth selection; diagnostic test; kernel smoothing; optimal cut-point.