The spillover effects of focused deterrence on gang violence

Eval Rev. Jun-Aug 2013;37(3-4):314-42. doi: 10.1177/0193841X13518535. Epub 2014 Feb 25.

Abstract

Background: Focused deterrence strategies attempt to increase punishment risks faced by violent gangs through the development of new and creative ways of deploying traditional and non-traditional law enforcement tools. In addition to increasing the swiftness and certainty of sanctions, these strategies explicitly communicate incentives and disincentives to deter likely gang offenders from violent behavior.

Objective: This study seeks to determine whether focused deterrence strategies generate spillover deterrent effects on the gun violence behaviors of vicariously treated gangs that were socially tied to directly treated violent gangs.

Research design: A nonrandomized quasi-experimental design was used to evaluate the gun violence reduction effects of focused deterrence strategies on directly treated gangs and vicariously treated gangs. Propensity score matching techniques were used to identify balanced comparison gangs for the vicariously treated gangs. Growth curve regression models were used to analyze gun violence trends for treated gangs relative to comparison gangs.

Unit of analysis: Quarterly counts of fatal and non-fatal shootings involving specific street gangs between 2006 and 2010 served as the units of analysis.

Measures: Key outcome measures included quarterly shootings committed by specific gangs, shooting victimizations suffered by specific gangs, and the total number of shootings involving specific gangs.

Results: The focused deterrence strategy was associated with statistically significant reductions in total shootings by directly treated gangs and vicariously treated gangs.

Conclusions: Our study finds that vicariously treated gangs were deterred by the treatment experiences of their rivals and allies. This suggests that focused deterrence strategies can generate spillover crime reduction effects to gangs that are socially connected to directly treated gangs.

Keywords: deterrence; difference-in-differences; diffusion of benefits; gangs; quasi-experimentation.

MeSH terms

  • Boston / epidemiology
  • Crime / prevention & control*
  • Criminal Law / methods
  • Firearms
  • Humans
  • Law Enforcement / methods
  • Police
  • Violence / prevention & control*
  • Wounds, Gunshot / epidemiology
  • Wounds, Gunshot / mortality