Skip to main page content
Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
, 46 (4), 281-91

Unacknowledged Threats Proffered "In a Manner of Speaking": Recognizing Workplace Bullying as Shaming


Unacknowledged Threats Proffered "In a Manner of Speaking": Recognizing Workplace Bullying as Shaming

Laura Cox Dzurec et al. J Nurs Scholarsh.


Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine workplace bullying victims' perceptions of what they heard their bully counterparts say through their use of prosody.

Design: From a sampling frame of 89 manuscripts referenced in the authors' previous studies, we identified a subset (n = 10) that included quotes regarding bullying victims' perceptions of communication experiences with their bully perpetrators.

Methods: We used hermeneutics and a recursive metasynthesis to interpret quotes embedded in the manuscripts chosen for this study.

Findings: Two-thirds of language is expressed nonverbally through prosody or "manner of speaking"-rhythm, stress, intonation, and vocabulary choice. We found that as bullies communicated with their intended victims over time, they used prosody across subtle, linked communications, or boldly and openly in public venues, to establish a context-embedded, one-way communication process of "doublespeak."

Conclusions: Bullies' confusing prosodic communication processes served to recontexualize victims' situations and, through mechanisms largely unacknowledged by the victims, to subtly demean their personhood, and to shame them and render them voiceless.

Clinical relevance: This study directs formal attention to the language of workplace bullying. Further study might strengthen opportunities to effectively address and curtail the long-term personal, professional, and organizational injuries deriving from workplace bullying.

Keywords: Workplace bullying; nonverbal language; policy; subjectivity.

Similar articles

  • The Incongruity of Workplace Bullying Victimization and Inclusive Excellence
    LC Dzurec et al. Nurs Outlook 65 (5), 588-596. PMID 28455111.
    Findings suggest that, as Heidegger contended, we are our histories. Personal history demonstrates a significance influence on the manifestation of bullying victimization …
  • Speaking of Workplace Bullying
    LC Dzurec et al. J Prof Nurs 28 (4), 247-54. PMID 22818195.
    Despite the increasing frequency of its reported incidence, especially in health care practice and education settings, workplace bullying seems to defy victims' clear und …
  • Bullying Among Nurses and Its Effects
    D Yildirim. Int Nurs Rev 56 (4), 504-11. PMID 19930081.
    Workplace bullying is a measurable problem that negatively affects the psychology and performance of the nurses in this study.
  • International Perspectives on Workplace Bullying Among Nurses: A Review
    SL Johnson. Int Nurs Rev 56 (1), 34-40. PMID 19239514. - Review
    More nurse-specific research is needed in this area. Research needs to be conducted in a systematic and uniform manner so that generalizations across studies can be made. …
  • Incivility and Bullying in the Workplace and Nurses' Shame Responses
    DM Felblinger. J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs 37 (2), 234-41; quiz 241-2. PMID 18336449. - Review
    Incivility and bullying in the workplace are intimidating forces that result in shame responses and threaten the well-being of nurses. Some nurses are accustomed to toler …
See all similar articles

Cited by 1 PubMed Central articles

  • Commentary: The Effect of Words on Health and Diabetes
    JK Dickinson. Diabetes Spectr 30 (1), 11-16. PMID 28270710.
    This article discusses the effect of words on diabetes. People with diabetes are exposed to the language health care professionals (HCPs) use, in both speaking and writin …

LinkOut - more resources