We present a species-wide comparative analysis of 90 genomes of Propionibacterium acnes that represent the known diversity of the species. Our results are augmented by six high-quality genomes and a manual investigation of all gene-sized indels found in the strains. Overall, the order of genes is conserved throughout the species. A public sybil database for easy comparative analysis of the 90 genomes was established. The analysis of indels revealed a total of 66 loci of non-core genes that correlate with phylogenetic clades. No gene was strain-specific in agreement with our conclusion that the P. acnes pan-genome is closed. An exhaustive search for homopolymeric tracts (HPTs) identified a total of 54 variable-length HPTs almost exclusively of guanine/cytosines located between genes or affecting the reading frame of genes. The repeat variation was consistent with phylogenetic clades suggesting slow accumulation over time rather than active modification. By transcriptome analysis we demonstrate how an HPT variation can affect the gene expression levels. Selected cases of both indels and HPTs are described. The catalogued data and the public P. acnes Sybil database provide a solid foundation for generating hypotheses and facilitate comparative genetic analyses in future P. acnes research.