Variation in Payment Rates under Medicare's Inpatient Prospective Payment System

Abstract

Objective: To measure variation in payment rates under Medicare's Inpatient Prospective Payment System (IPPS) and identify the main payment adjustments that drive variation.

Data sources/study setting: Medicare cost reports for all Medicare-certified hospitals, 1987-2013, and Dartmouth Atlas geographic files.

Study design: We measure the Medicare payment rate as a hospital's total acute inpatient Medicare Part A payment, divided by the standard IPPS payment for its geographic area. We assess variation using several measures, both within local markets and nationally. We perform a factor decomposition to identify the share of variation attributable to specific adjustments. We also describe the characteristics of hospitals receiving different payment rates and evaluate changes in the magnitude of the main adjustments over time.

Data collection/extraction methods: Data downloaded from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the National Bureau of Economic Research, and the Dartmouth Atlas.

Principal findings: In 2013, Medicare paid for acute inpatient discharges at a rate 31 percent above the IPPS base. For the top 10 percent of discharges, the mean rate was double the IPPS base. Variations were driven by adjustments for medical education and care to low-income populations. The magnitude of variation has increased over time.

Conclusions: Adjustments are a large and growing share of Medicare hospital payments, and they create significant variation in payment rates.

Keywords: Medicare; health care costs; hospitals; price variation; prospective payment.

Figure 1

Relationship between Teaching Intensity, Care to Low‐Income Populations, and Part A Payment Rates, 2013 Notes: Each marker represent a hospital. For clarity, five outlying observations representing 0.18 percent of discharges are not shown. Added lines represent the mean resident‐to‐bed ratio and DSH patient percentages, respectively, weighted by Part A discharges. Source: Medicare cost reports, authors’ calculations.

Figure 2

Part A Payment Rates, by Payment Component, 2013 Notes: Values are the mean of Part A discharges within each grouping. Source: Medicare cost reports, authors’ calculations.

Figure 3

Percent of Aggregate Part A Payment, by Payment Component, 1987–2013 Notes: Y‐axis begins at 60 percent. Source: Medicare cost reports, authors’ calculations.

Figure 4

Part A Payment Rates, by Payment Decile, 1987–2013 Notes: Y‐axis begins at 0.75. Vertical lines mark transitions to new cost report versions. Source: Medicare hospital cost reports, authors’ calculations.