Although magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) excels in a number of medical imaging utilities, one of its particular attraction is the lack of ionizing radiation. However, MRI scans are associated with their own unique safety concerns. We encountered two cases of lost tragus piercings presenting as a novel risk factor in MRI safety. The lost tragus piercings caused temporary discomfort and pain but were able to be removed without complication. Heightened awareness for this potential source of patient harm, particularly with more individuals obtaining body piercings, is necessary for appropriate patient screening.