Long-term Durability of Infrainguinal Endovascular and Open Revascularization for Disabling Claudication

Abstract

Background: Infrainguinal revascularization for disabling claudication (DC) is frequently performed, but long-term results are still unknown. In this study, we compared clinical outcomes of infrainguinal endovascular (EV) and open interventions for DC after the failure of medical management.

Methods: One hundred ninety-four patients with DC (Rutherford category 3) who had open (n = 53) or EV (n = 141) interventions were grouped as open-great saphenous vein (GSV) (n = 21), open-prosthetic (n = 32), EV-Trans-Atlantic Inter-Society Consensus II (TASC II) A and B (AB) (n = 48), and EV-TASC II C and D (CD) (n = 93). Patency, primary clinical success (PCS; sustained improvement in symptoms without reintervention), and secondary clinical success (SCS; sustained improvement in symptoms with reintervention) rates were compared.

Results: Mean follow-up was 57 ± 33 months. Five-year primary patency was 58% in open-GSV, 40% in open-prosthetic, 72% in EV-AB, and 38% in EV-CD (P < 0.001). Five-year secondary patency was 77% in open-GSV, 50% in open-prosthetic, 96% in EV-AB, and 61% in EV-CD (P < 0.001). Freedom from major adverse limb events was 73% in open-GSV, 77% in EV-AB, 70% in EV-CD, and 67% in open-prosthetic (P = 0.279). Five-year PCS was 46% in open-GSV, 40% in open-prosthetic, 57% in EV-AB, and 44% in EV-CD (P = 0.02). Five-year SCS was 78% in open-GSV, 78% in open-prosthetic, 85% in EV-AB, and 84% in EV-CD (P = 0.732). A total of 116 reinterventions were performed, 10 in 6 limbs (27%) in open-GSV, 18 in 12 limbs (36%) in open-prosthetic, 26 in 15 limbs (24%) in EV-AB, and 62 in 39 limbs (36%) in EV-CD. Reinterventions included 71 (61%) EV and 45 (39%) open procedures.

Conclusions: Durability of infrainguinal interventions in claudicants depends mainly on anatomic complexity of disease. Good long-term clinical success can be achieved with both open and EV interventions, albeit with high reintervention rates, especially in patients with TASC II C and D disease. A considerable subset of EV patients will eventually require surgical revascularization to maintain clinical benefit. In this study, almost 20% of patients undergoing EV for TASC II C and D disease eventually required surgical bypass.