Interspecific competition for resources leading to niche partitioning is considered as one of the major drivers of community assembly. Competitive niche partitioning is diagnosed from species co-occurrence, species abundance distributions (SADs), and body size distributions of species. For several decades, studies have explored these patterns for the relative significance of interspecific competition in shaping communities. We explored these patterns in a finite assemblage of insectivorous lizards in the Andaman & Nicobar Islands, both at the level of archipelago and individual islands. Negative geographic co-occurrences occurred only between species pairs in islands separated by deep ocean channels. Ecologically similar species did not show positive co-occurrence in guild co-occurrence analyses, indicating that the negative geographical co-occurrences between species in islands were due to historical allopatry. Species abundance distribution was best explained by a Pareto distribution in both metacommunity and local communities. There was no predictable spacing of body sizes among co-existing species in local communities. The empirical data on insular lizard community on species co-occurrence, SADs, and body size ratios does not lend support to assortment of species in islands caused by niche subdivision. Such niche-dissociated assembly of species in islands might be an important factor in formation of biological communities, regardless of geographic scale.