Overexpansion of the SAPIEN 3 Transcatheter Heart Valve: An Ex Vivo Bench Study

Abstract

Objectives: This study assessed the effect of overexpansion beyond labeled size (diameter) of transcatheter heart valves through an ex vivo bench study.

Background: Transcatheter heart valves function optimally when expanded to specific dimensions. However, clinicians may sometimes wish to overexpand balloon-expandable valves to address specific clinical challenges. The implications of overexpansion have assumed considerable importance, and objective information to guide practice is limited.

Methods: We evaluated SAPIEN 3 transcatheter heart valves (Edwards Lifesciences, Irvine, California). Valves (diameters of 23, 26, and 29 mm) were expanded to nominal dimensions, and then incrementally overexpanded with balloons sized 1-, 2-, and 3-mm larger than the recommended diameter. Valves underwent visual, microcomputed tomography, and hydrodynamic evaluation at various degrees of overexpansion.

Results: SAPIEN 3 valves with labeled diameters of 23, 26, and 29 mm could be incrementally overexpanded to midvalve diameters of 26.4, 28.4, and 31.2 mm, respectively. With overexpansion, there was visible restriction of the valve leaflets, which was particularly evident with the smaller valves. After maximal overexpansion of a 26-mm valve a leaflet tear was observed. High-speed video demonstrated impaired leaflet motion of both the 23- and 26-mm valves and hydrodynamic testing documented a regurgitant fraction for the 23- and 26-mm valves above accepted international standards. The maximally overexpanded 29-mm SAPIEN 3 still had relatively normal leaflet motion and excellent hydrodynamic function. Durability was not specifically evaluated.

Conclusions: Overexpansion of balloon-expandable valves is possible. However, excessive overexpansion may be associated with impaired hydrodynamic function, acute leaflet failure, and reduced durability. Smaller valves may be at greater risk with overexpansion than larger valves. Overexpansion is best avoided unless clinical circumstances are compelling.

Keywords: overexpansion; transcatheter heart valve.