Although surface geology, eruption information and clustering seismicity all suggest Turtle Island (Kueishantao) of northern Taiwan is an active volcano, there was no direct evidence to conclude that magma reservoirs exist beneath it. Even less evidence is available to determine their spatial configuration. If the magma reservoirs are filled by liquids and melt, S-waves are totally reflected and leave behind a shadow, like when passing through the Earth's outer core. We detect both these S-wave shadows and strong reflections from the surface using earthquakes at different depths and azimuths. These observations identify a km-scale molten-filled volume located beneath Turtle Island. The magmatic nature of the reservoir is supported by the onset of non-double-couple earthquakes with strong CLVD (Compensated Linear Vector Dipole) and ISO (Isotropic) components, which show a tensor crack compatible with some volume changes within the reservoir. Combining these results with two independent 3-D velocity models and aeromagnetic anomalies recorded in Taiwan, a partially-molten ~19% low-velocity volume is estimated in the mid-crust (13-23 km), with spatial uncertainties of ~3 km. The elongated direction approximately follows the strike of the Okinawa trough, indicating that the source of the magma reservoir might be a back-arc opening.