Resection rates and safety profile of cold vs. hot snare polypectomy in polyps sized 5-10 mm and 11-20 mm

Abstract

Background and aims: Hot snare (HS) is widely used for the resection of adenomas >5 mm. The cold snare (CS) has a better safety profile and is more cost-effective. The aims of this study were to evaluate effectiveness and safety of CS polypectomy (CSP) compared to HS polypectomy (HSP) for adenomas sized 5-10 mm and 11-20 mm.

Methods: 4018 colonoscopies performed within "quality certificate for screening colonoscopy" with one polypectomy of an adenoma sized 5-20 mm each were included. Retrieval rates, complete resection rates and complication rates were assessed and compared between CSP and HSP for adenomas sized 5-10 mm and 11-20 mm. Histologic subgroups were additionally assessed.

Results: Complete resection rates (5-10 mm: CSP: 89.4% vs. HSP: 87.9%, p = 0.33; 11-20 mm: CSP: 81.8% vs. 80.9%; p = 1), retrieval rates (5-10 mm: CSP: 99.5% vs. HSP: 99.4%, p = 0.76; 11-20 mm: CSP: 100% vs. HSP: 99%, p = 1) and complication rates (5-10 mm: CSP: 0.2% vs. HSP: 0.2%; p = 1; 11-20 mm: CSP: 0% vs. HSP: 1%, p = 1) were equal between CSP and HSP for adenomas sized 5-10 mm as well as 11-20 mm. For serrated adenomas sized 5-10 mm, HSP was superior to CSP (88.7% vs. 77.2%, p < 0.05) regarding the complete resection rate, but not for advanced adenomas (HSP: 89.1% vs. 87.3%, p = 0.69) or adenomas with high-grade dysplasia (HSP: 76.7% vs. 75%, p = 1).

Conclusion: This study further supports the use of CSP for polyps sized 5-10 mm and additionally suggests also using CSP for polyps sized 11-20 mm. These findings, as well as the best method for resection of serrated polyps should be validated in further studies.

Keywords: Cold snare; Colonoscopy; Colorectal cancer screening; Polypectomy.