Valuing the health states associated with breast cancer screening programmes: A systematic review of economic measures

Soc Sci Med. 2019 May;228:142-154. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2019.03.028. Epub 2019 Mar 21.


Policy decisions regarding breast cancer screening and treatment programmes may be misplaced unless the decision process includes the appropriate utilities and disutilities of mammography screening and its sequelae. The objectives of this study were to critically review how economic evaluations have valued the health states associated with breast cancer screening, and appraise the primary evidence informing health state utility values (cardinal measures of quality of life). A systematic review was conducted up to September 2018 of studies that elicited or used utilities relevant to mammography screening. The methods used to elicit utilities and the quality of the reported values were tabulated and analysed narratively. 40 economic evaluations of breast cancer screening programmes and 10 primary studies measuring utilities for health states associated with mammography were reviewed in full. The economic evaluations made different assumptions about the measures used, duration applied and the sequalae included in each health state. 22 evaluations referenced utilities based on assumptions or used measures that were not methodologically appropriate. There was significant heterogeneity in the utilities generated by the 10 primary studies, including the methods and population used to derive them. No study asked women to explicitly consider the risk of overdiagnosis when valuing the health states described. Utilities informing breast screening policy are restricted in their ability to reflect the full benefits and harms. Evaluating the true cost-effectiveness of breast cancer screening will remain problematic, unless the methodological challenges associated with valuing the disutilities of screening are adequately addressed.

Keywords: Breast cancer; Health state utility value; Mammography; QALY; Quality of life; Screening.

Publication types

  • Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't
  • Systematic Review

MeSH terms

  • Adult
  • Breast Neoplasms / diagnosis*
  • Early Detection of Cancer / economics
  • Early Detection of Cancer / methods
  • Female
  • Healthcare Financing
  • Humans
  • Mass Screening / economics*
  • Mass Screening / methods
  • Mass Screening / trends
  • Middle Aged
  • Quality-Adjusted Life Years