Gender differences in math performance are now small in developed countries and they cannot explain on their own the strong underrepresentation of women in math-related fields. This latter result is however no longer true once gender differences in reading performance are also taken into account. Using individual-level data on 300,000 15-y-old students in 64 countries, we show that the difference between a student performance in reading and math is 80% of a standard deviation (SD) larger for girls than boys, a magnitude considered as very large. When this difference is controlled for, the gender gap in students' intentions to pursue math-intensive studies and careers is reduced by around 75%, while gender gaps in self-concept in math, declared interest for math or attitudes toward math entirely disappear. These latter variables are also much less able to explain the gender gap in intentions to study math than is students' difference in performance between math and reading. These results are in line with choice models in which educational decisions involve intraindividual comparisons of achievement and self-beliefs in different subjects as well as cultural norms regarding gender. To directly show that intraindividual comparisons of achievement impact students' intended careers, we use differences across schools in teaching resources dedicated to math and reading as exogenous variations of students' comparative advantage for math. Results confirm that the comparative advantage in math with respect to reading at the time of making educational choices plays a key role in the process leading to women's underrepresentation in math-intensive fields.
Keywords: comparative advantage; gender gap; math-intensive fields; students’ achievement.
Conflict of interest statement
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Women in Academic Science: A Changing LandscapeSJ Ceci et al. Psychol Sci Public Interest 15 (3), 75-141. PMID 26172066.Much has been written in the past two decades about women in academic science careers, but this literature is contradictory. Many analyses have revealed a level playing f …
Self-Concept and Achievement in Math Among Australian Primary Students: Gender and Culture IssuesF Han. Front Psychol 10, 603. PMID 30971976.While gender stereotype on math learning and achievement is consistently reported among existing research, these studies predominantly focus on mainstream students with W …
Math Achievement Is Important, but Task Values Are Critical, Too: Examining the Intellectual and Motivational Factors Leading to Gender Disparities in STEM CareersMT Wang et al. Front Psychol 6, 36. PMID 25741292.Although young women now obtain higher course grades in math than boys and are just as likely to be enrolled in advanced math courses in high school, females continue to …
Women's Underrepresentation in Science: Sociocultural and Biological ConsiderationsSJ Ceci et al. Psychol Bull 135 (2), 218-61. PMID 19254079. - ReviewThe underrepresentation of women at the top of math-intensive fields is controversial, with competing claims of biological and sociocultural causation. The authors develo …
Gendered Pathways: How Mathematics Ability Beliefs Shape Secondary and Postsecondary Course and Degree Field ChoicesL Perez-Felkner et al. Front Psychol 8, 386. PMID 28428762. - ReviewDo mathematics ability beliefs explain gender gaps in the physical science, engineering, mathematics, and computer science fields (PEMC) and other science fields? We leve …