Music and Metronomes Differentially Impact Motor Timing in People with and without Parkinson's Disease: Effects of Slow, Medium, and Fast Tempi on Entrainment and Synchronization Performances in Finger Tapping, Toe Tapping, and Stepping on the Spot Tasks

Abstract

Introduction: Rhythmic auditory stimulation (RAS) has successfully helped regulate gait for people with Parkinson's disease. However, the way in which different auditory cues and types of movements affect entrainment, synchronization, and pacing stability has not been directly compared in different aged people with and without Parkinson's. Therefore, this study compared music and metronomes (cue types) in finger tapping, toe tapping, and stepping on the spot tasks to explore the potential of RAS training for general use.

Methods: Participants (aged 18-78 years) included people with Parkinson's (n = 30, Hoehn and Yahr mean = 1.78), older (n = 26), and younger adult controls (n = 36), as age may effect motor timing. Timed motor production was assessed using an extended synchronization-continuation task in cue type and movement conditions for slow, medium, and fast tempi (81, 116, and 140 mean beats per minute, respectively).

Results: Analyses revealed main effects of cue and movement type but no between-group interactions, suggesting no differences in motor timing between people with Parkinson's and controls. Music supported entrainment better than metronomes in medium and fast tempi, and stepping on the spot enabled better entrainment and less asynchrony, as well as more stable pacing compared to tapping in medium and fast tempi. Age was not confirmed as a factor, and no differences were observed in slow tempo.

Conclusion: This is the first study to directly compare how different external auditory cues and movement types affect motor timing. The music and the stepping enabled participants to maintain entrainment once the external pacing cue ceased, suggesting endogenous mechanisms continued to regulate the movements. The superior performance of stepping on the spot suggests embodied entrainment can occur during continuous movement, and this may be related to emergent timing in tempi above 600 ms. These findings can be applied therapeutically to manage and improve adaptive behaviours for people with Parkinson's.

Figure 1

Stepping on the spot and finger- and toe-tapping equipment and actions.

Figure 2

The main effect of cue type on entrainment ability (IRI % Error) collapsed across all groups in each tempo. Y-axis shows IRI % Error. X-axis shows the temporal nature of the experimental paradigm.

Figure 3

The significant main effect of cue type on entrainment ability (IRI % Error) and the significant interaction between groups in the fast tempo. Y-axis shows IRI % Error. X-axis shows the temporal nature of the experimental paradigm.

Figure 4

The significant main effect of movement modality on entrainment ability (IRI % Error) and the significant interaction between groups in the medium tempo. Y-axis shows IRI % Error. X-axis shows the temporal nature of the experimental paradigm.

Figure 5

The effect of cue type on Absolute Asynchrony in all tempi by group. Y-axis shows the mean of Sync A and Sync B Absolute Asynchrony in ms. X-axis shows group by cue type.

Figure 6

The effect of movement modality on Absolute Asynchrony in all tempi by group. Y-axis shows Absolute Asynchrony in ms. X-axis shows group by movement modality.