Background: Synthetic Cartilage Implantation (SCI; Cartiva) is a treatment of hallux rigidus associated with mixed clinical outcomes in the United States. Patients with persistent pain typically undergo diagnostic imaging for evaluation. We aimed to characterize the radiologic findings of SCI and surrounding tissues.
Methods: This is a retrospective review of patients treated using SCI who underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for persistent pain. Metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint spaces were compared on plain radiographs of the foot immediately postoperatively and at most recent follow-up. MRI of the foot were assessed for dimensions of the implant, bony channel, and presence of peri-implant fluid. Clinical follow-up, including Patient-Reported Outcome Measures Informational System (PROMIS) scores, satisfaction rating, and revision surgery, was collected. Eighteen cases of symptomatic SCI from 16 patients (13 females, 3 males) were included. All but 1 case involved a 10-mm implant.
Results: Mean satisfaction rating was 2.25 (1-5 Likert scale). PROMIS scores indicated moderate physical dysfunction (41) and moderate pain interference (63). Six of 16 patients (37.5%) underwent revision surgery at average 20.9 months of follow-up. Plain radiographs over a 13.3-month interval showed joint space narrowing of 2 mm medially and 1.6 mm laterally (P < .001). One hundred percent of cases had radiographic evidence of osteoarthritis (OA) progression. MRI studies were obtained on average 11.5 months postoperatively. The implant diameter averaged 9.7 mm, which mismatched the bony channel diameter of 11.2 mm (P < .001). Fourteen of 18 cases had peri-implant fluid. All cases had edema in the metatarsal, proximal phalanx, and soft tissues.
Conclusion: Radiographic loss of MTP joint space and progression of arthritis were present for all cases studied. MRI revealed bony channel widening and a smaller implant, with peri-implant fluid suggesting instability at the implant-bone interface. Persistent edema was observed in soft tissues and bone. Diagnostic imaging of SCI in symptomatic patients demonstrated concerning findings that merit further correlation with patient outcomes.
Level of evidence: Level IV, case series.
Keywords: Cartiva; hallux rigidus; hemiarthroplasty; hydrogel implant; synthetic cartilage implant.
Early Outcomes and Complications of Synthetic Cartilage Implant for Treatment of Hallux Rigidus in the United StatesSJ Cassinelli et al. Foot Ankle Int 40 (10), 1140-1148. PMID 31195830.Synthetic cartilage implantation yielded neutral patient satisfaction, mild pain, and physical dysfunction at early follow-up. We believe patient selection and counseling …
Midterm Outcomes of Polyvinyl Alcohol Hydrogel Hemiarthroplasty of the First Metatarsophalangeal Joint in Advanced Hallux RigidusTR Daniels et al. Foot Ankle Int 38 (3), 243-247. PMID 27909032.Five years following first MTP hemiarthroplasty with a PVA hydrogel implant, functional outcomes improved significantly, pain was reduced significantly, and the implant d …
Association Between Patient Factors and Outcome of Synthetic Cartilage Implant Hemiarthroplasty vs First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis in Advanced Hallux RigidusA Goldberg et al. Foot Ankle Int 38 (11), 1199-1206. PMID 28820949. - Randomized Controlled TrialSynthetic cartilage implant hemiarthroplasty was appropriate for patients with grade 2, 3, or 4 hallux rigidus. Its results in those with associated mild hallux valgus (≤ …
Hallux Rigidus: Demographics, Etiology, and Radiographic AssessmentMJ Coughlin et al. Foot Ankle Int 24 (10), 731-43. PMID 14587987. - ReviewHallux rigidus was not associated with elevatus, first ray hypermobility, a long first metatarsal, Achilles or gastrocnemius tendon tightness, abnormal foot posture, symp …
New Technology in the Treatment of Hallux Rigidus With a Synthetic Cartilage Implant HemiarthroplastyJF Baumhauer et al. Orthop Clin North Am 50 (1), 109-118. PMID 30477700. - ReviewSynthetic cartilage implant surgery is an excellent option for the patient with great toe arthritis and good alignment of the toe who wishes to retain first metatarsophal …