5-Fluorouracil (5-FU) is a chemotherapeutic drug commonly used for the treatment of solid cancers. It is proposed that 5-FU interferes with nucleotide synthesis and incorporates into DNA, which may have a mutational impact on both surviving tumor and healthy cells. Here, we treat intestinal organoids with 5-FU and find a highly characteristic mutational pattern that is dominated by T>G substitutions in a CTT context. Tumor whole genome sequencing data confirms that this signature is also identified in vivo in colorectal and breast cancer patients who have received 5-FU treatment. Taken together, our results demonstrate that 5-FU is mutagenic and may drive tumor evolution and increase the risk of secondary malignancies. Furthermore, the identified signature shows a strong resemblance to COSMIC signature 17, the hallmark signature of treatment-naive esophageal and gastric tumors, which indicates that distinct endogenous and exogenous triggers can converge onto highly similar mutational signatures.