The Presence of 'Um' as a Marker of Truthfulness in the Speech of TV Personalities
- PMID: 31983973
- PMCID: PMC6818394
- DOI: 10.1080/13218719.2016.1256018
The Presence of 'Um' as a Marker of Truthfulness in the Speech of TV Personalities
Abstract
The aim of this study is to determine whether the presence of the interjection 'um' can distinguish between the deceptive and truthful speech of individuals who are practised in the art of impression management. A total of 50 truthful and 61 deceptive statements were extracted from the speech of celebrities participating in a televised comedy panel show where celebrity guests try to convince an opposing team of their truthfulness. Participants' use of 'um' (measured as a percentage of the total word count of each statement) was analysed. The results show that, on average, 'um' was used almost three times as often in the speakers' true statements compared to their false ones. A discriminant analysis revealed that the presence of 'um' is more effective than human judgement alone in determining veracity. These findings suggest that the presence of the filler 'um' in speech is useful in the identification of true versus false oral statements.
Keywords: deception; lie detection; linguistic markers of lying; lying; ‘um’.
© 2016 The Australian and New Zealand Association of Psychiatry, Psychology and Law.
Conflict of interest statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.
Similar articles
-
The Effect of Statement Type and Repetition on Deception DetectionDK Cash et al. Cogn Res Princ Implic 4 (1), 38. PMID 31549260.The results show that repeated statements as well as shorter denials can increase the difficulty of differentiating truthful from deceptive statements. Additionally, thes …
-
Efficacy of Forensic Statement Analysis in Distinguishing Truthful From Deceptive Eyewitness Accounts of Highly Stressful EventsCA Morgan 3rd et al. J Forensic Sci 56 (5), 1227-34. PMID 21854383. - Randomized Controlled TrialLaboratory-based detecting deception research suggests that truthful statements differ from those of deceptive statements. This nonlaboratory study tested whether forensi …
-
Cues to Lying May Be Deceptive: Speaker and Listener Behaviour in an Interactive Game of DeceptionJE Loy et al. J Cogn 1 (1), 42. PMID 31517215.Are the cues that speakers produce when lying the same cues that listeners attend to when attempting to detect deceit? We used a two-person interactive game to explore th …
-
Using Uh and Um in Spontaneous SpeakingHH Clark et al. Cognition 84 (1), 73-111. PMID 12062148. - ReviewThe proposal examined here is that speakers use uh and um to announce that they are initiating what they expect to be a minor (uh), or major (um), delay in speaking. Spea …
-
When Lying Changes Memory for the TruthH Otgaar et al. Memory 26 (1), 2-14. PMID 28661223. - ReviewIn the legal field, victims and offenders frequently lie to avoid talking about serious incidents, such as past experiences of sexual abuse or criminal involvement. Altho …
Grant support
LinkOut - more resources
Full Text Sources