Psychologists' Psychologies of Psychologists in a Time of Crisis
- PMID: 31999140
- DOI: 10.1037/hop0000140
Psychologists' Psychologies of Psychologists in a Time of Crisis
Abstract
Beset by detection of replication failures and questionable research practices over the last decade, psychology has been deemed by many to be in crisis. The situation is exceptional not only for the many investigative practices being scrutinized but also for the attention given to the undue influence of psychologists' psychology on those practices. Comparative analysis of 2 crises finds that the earlier one focused on the experimenters' activities within the laboratory, whereas the current concerns center on experimenters' postexperimental work. Whereas the previous crisis did include deep concerns about experimenters, the currently offered psychologies of fellow psychologists are distinctive in their frequency, intensity, and considerable reliance upon established knowledge about human thought and behavior. In so utilizing scientific psychology to assess psychology, the current appraisals give richer evidence of the circuitry of psychological knowledge as it travels from the laboratory outward and back. They give considerable attention to the scientists' moral characteristics, whereas the earlier crisis generated concerns about experimenters' conduct in the laboratory and the politics surrounding the application of psychological knowledge. Through their direct discussions of personal and moral conduct, the assessments also resonate with uncertainties about scientists' self-control, normative ethics, and emotions. Taken together, the psychologies and attendant uncertainties illuminate present conditions of psychology's scientific self and invite reflection on the close connections between that self, ethos, and epistemology. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).
Similar articles
-
[A Proposal for Reforming Psychologists' Training in France and in the European Union]JP Bouchard. Encephale 35 (1), 18-24. PMID 19250989.It is more than ever essential to develop and update in excellence the high level "psy" generalist profession, the profession of psychologist, which users need in many fi …
-
Psychology's Replication Crisis and Clinical Psychological ScienceJL Tackett et al. Annu Rev Clin Psychol 15, 579-604. PMID 30673512.Despite psychological scientists' increasing interest in replicability, open science, research transparency, and the improvement of methods and practices, the clinical ps …
-
Psychology's RenaissanceLD Nelson et al. Annu Rev Psychol 69, 511-534. PMID 29068778. - ReviewIn 2010-2012, a few largely coincidental events led experimental psychologists to realize that their approach to collecting, analyzing, and reporting data made it too eas …
-
Feminism and Psychology: Critiques of Methods and EpistemologyAH Eagly et al. Am Psychol 69 (7), 685-702. PMID 25046701. - ReviewStarting in the 1960s, many of the critiques of psychological science offered by feminist psychologists focused on its methods and epistemology. This article evaluates th …
-
Epistemological Dizziness in the Psychology Laboratory: Lively Subjects, Anxious Experimenters, and Experimental Relations, 1950-1970J Morawski. Isis 106 (3), 567-97. PMID 26685518.Since the demise of introspective techniques in the early twentieth century, experimental psychology has largely assumed an administrative arrangement between experimente …