For the first time, we describe the stereocontrolled total syntheses of olivil, cephafortin A, 4-des-O-methyl-4-O-rhamnosyl cephafortin A, and alashinol F from a common precursor using a combination of chemoenzymatic and biomimetic methods for the systematic introduction of functional groups on three vicinal stereogenic carbon atoms. We revised the previously assigned stereochemistry of (+)-cephafortin A, which was reported as the enantiomer. Natural and unnatural congeners provide insights into the biogenetic interrelations of members of this family.