Can the South African Milestones for Reducing Exposure to Respirable Crystalline Silica and Silicosis be Achieved and Reliably Monitored?

Abstract

Silicosis and other respirable crystalline silica-associated diseases, most notably tuberculosis, have long been substantial causes of morbidity and mortality in South Africa. For the mining and non-mining industries, silicosis elimination programmes have been developed with milestones regarding reduction of levels of exposure to respirable crystalline silica (RCS) and targets regarding the date of eradication. The present paper explores the feasibility of achieving these targets by investigating the evidence that levels of exposure and silicosis incidence rates have declined by an appraisal of the methods for data collection and reporting. In the mining industry the silicosis elimination programme is supported by the development and advocacy of leading practices to reduce the exposure. RCS exposure data are routinely collected according to a Code of Practice (CoP) and the results are reported to the Mine Health and Safety Inspectorate. As the CoP and the actual workplace practices have been demonstrated to have some flaws, there is some concern about the accuracy of the actual exposure data and the data interpretation. The annually reported levels of exposure suggest a decline, however, the actual levels of RCS as well as the number of exposed workers, were not reported over the last few years. With regard to the silicosis incidence rates, a steady decline of new cases is reported. However, there is a risk of under-diagnosis and- reporting especially in former miners. In the non-mining industries, a systematic baseline of RCS exposure levels and silicosis incidence is lacking. The reporting by industries on assigning of the workforce to exposure categories seems to be fragmented and incomplete. Consequently, any evidence of progress toward achieving the silicosis elimination target cannot be documented. Both the silicosis elimination target and the exposure milestone are aspirational but are unlikely to be achieved. Nevertheless, the formal mining industry may get close. Exposure control interventions, especially in the non-mining industries, should be developed and implemented and pragmatic methods need to be put in place to identify sources of new silicosis cases for targeted intervention.

Keywords: bias; data analysis; exposure control; grouping; under-reporting and diagnosis.